Commentary: Alabama minister ‘never lost himself in the battle’

Translate Page
Note: The Rev. Stephen Dill was an Alabama-West Florida Conference minister for 40 years, including 18 years as senior minister at Dauphin Way United Methodist Church in Mobile, Alabama. He held many other church and community posts.

Key points

  • The Rev. Stephen Dill served 40 years as an Alabama-West Florida Conference pastor and held many other church and civic posts.
  • He took an early stand for civil rights but managed throughout his career to avoid distancing himself from those he disagreed with.
  • His sermons are collected in the book “The Poetry of Faith: Sermons Preached in a Southern Church.”

Frye Gaillard. Photo by Rachel Smook. 
Frye Gaillard.
Photo by Rachel Smook.


UM News publishes various commentaries about issues in the denomination. The opinion pieces reflect a variety of viewpoints and are the opinions of the writers, not the UM News staff.

My friend Steve Dill died the other day. He was 93 with a failing heart, so this was not entirely unexpected, but it is to me sadder than I have words to express. I am not alone in this.

Steve was a United Methodist minister who embodied the faith as I understand it — as a mystical presence; a source of mystery at least as much as it was of pious truth. He was 90 when he preached the eulogy for my wife Nancy; white-haired, ramrod straight, with a voice that had to remind you of God’s. On that occasion, he said, “When Nancy died, it was as if she ceased to meet us in a particular place in order to meet us everywhere.”

I found myself thinking of the first time Nancy and I heard Steve preach. At its Emancipation Day service, an African American church in Mobile asked him to deliver the white apology for slavery. For his sermon text, Steve chose the old Negro hymn, “Were You There When They Crucified My Lord?”

Of course, none of us was physically present for the crucifixion, just as none of us was alive to own slaves. But Steve quoted the hymn’s refrain: “Sometimes it causes me to tremble.” As he recounted the racial history of the country — a brilliant summary of the great American sin — he paused periodically to reaffirm, “Sometimes it causes me to tremble.”

Nancy leaned over to me and whispered, “You have to collect his sermons into a book, and you have to make sure it gets published.” So I did.

Frye Gaillard (right) visits with the Rev. Steve Dill and his wife, Ruth Dill. For Gaillard, Rev. Dill embodied the faith. The pastor died January 14 at age 93. Photo courtesy of Frye Gaillard. 
Frye Gaillard (right) visits with the Rev. Steve Dill and his wife, Ruth Dill. For Gaillard, Rev. Dill embodied the faith. The pastor died January 14 at age 93. Photo courtesy of Frye Gaillard.

In that book, “The Poetry of Faith: Sermons Preached in a Southern Church,” I wrote an introduction about Steve’s life — how his ministry was forged in the civil rights years when he stood for social justice and spoke against racial segregation. He did this in Alabama in the 1960s, when it was not easy.

But there was something else about him in those days. As his fellow minister Gorman Houston put it, “Steve never lost himself in the battle. That was what was so remarkable. He never distanced himself from the people he disagreed with. He had a pastoral way, never letting go of his strong stands, but also never letting go of his kindness.”

To which I added: “Almost invariably, the poetry of his preaching caught the quick of my imagination and quietly, inevitably made me think. … In saying this, I speak as a skeptic, as one afflicted by the shadow of doubt, but even more so as a reluctant critic of American Christianity — of the didactic shrillness emanating from so many of our pulpits. … You won’t find any of that from Steve Dill, nothing harsh, or narrow, or petty; nothing simplistic or disingenuous. Instead what you’ll discover is a rigorous mind in search of deeper truth, and a faith in the loving mysteries of God.”

Now we come to the moment of his passing. The human family is poorer today, less compassionate and wise, than it was with Steve in it. But there is hope for us, too, as we muster the grace to remember who he was. RIP, good friend.

Gaillard is the author of more than 30 books, exploring themes of social justice, Southern music, religion, politics and culture.

News media contact: Tim Tanton or Joey Butler, Nashville, Tennessee, (615) 742-5470 or To read more United Methodist news, subscribe to the free Daily or Friday (weekly) Digests.


Like what you're reading? Support the ministry of UM News! Your support ensures the latest denominational news, dynamic stories and informative articles will continue to connect our global community. Make a tax-deductible donation at

Sign up for our newsletter!

Church Leadership
The Rev. René Lawson. Photo courtesy of the author.

Clergy morale in today's time

Reports indicate that clergy burnout is at an all-time high. Showing them appreciation would go a long way.
Faith Stories
Jay Weaver, a founding member of popular Christian band Big Daddy Weave and a lifelong United Methodist, passed away from complications of COVID-19 on Jan 2. Photo courtesy of St. Paul United Methodist Church via Facebook.

Remembering Jay Weaver of Big Daddy Weave

The lifelong United Methodist was a founding member of the popular Christian music group. He passed away due to complications from COVID-19.
Multicultural Ministry
The three churches sharing Immanuel United Methodist Church’s facilities are represented in different languages on the sign in front of the church in Kenosha, Wis. The collaboration is reflected scripturally in the passage from Ecclesiastes 4:12: “A cord of three strands is not quickly broken.” Photo by the Rev. Peter Daekyu Lee.

Bilingual appointments give new life to declining Korean churches

The Wisconsin Conference’s new appointment initiative helps respond to the trend of declining Korean and other ethnic churches.